High-Profile Real Estate Brothers Face Growing Legal Troubles Amid Criminal Allegations

A series of new lawsuits have emerged against three affluent brothers accused of drugging and sexually assaulting numerous women across several states. The Alexander brothers claim that a prominent personal injury law firm influenced the criminal investigation against them.

Tal Alexander, 38, and Oren Alexander, 37, both successful real estate brokers with a lavish lifestyle in New York and Miami, along with their identical twin brother, Alon Alexander, were apprehended in Miami Beach on December 11 and remain in federal custody while awaiting trial in New York.

Prosecutors report that more than 60 alleged victims have come forward with accusations against the brothers. This week, 11 additional individuals filed claims in New York Supreme Court, further complicating the legal battle.

Andrew Van Arsdale, managing partner at AVA Law Group Inc., expressed the severity of the situation, stating, “There are a lot of victims, and the Alexander brothers deserve some form of accountability for sexually assaulting these women.” He represents the plaintiffs involved in the recent lawsuits.

According to the federal indictment filed in December, the brothers allegedly worked together, sometimes with others, to repeatedly and violently drug, assault, and rape their victims in New York, Miami, and other locations.

Charges Filed Against the Alexander Brothers

All three brothers face a charge of conspiracy to commit sex trafficking and sex trafficking of a woman through force, fraud, or coercion. Additionally, Tal Alexander is charged with the sex trafficking of a second victim, although all three men have pleaded not guilty to the allegations.

The complaints brought forth by the 11 women represent a range of locations, including Manhattan, Miami, and even Moscow. Most of the plaintiffs are filing their cases under pseudonyms to protect their identities, with only one, Leah Peters, publicly naming herself.

Peters reports that she met Oren Alexander at a luxurious house party in Miami in 2018. After engaging in conversation, he allegedly led her to a bedroom and assaulted her.

Disturbing Patterns of Assault

Similar stories emerged in the accusations filed by other women. One alleged victim states that after being invited to a party by Tal Alexander in New York City in July 2013, she was handed a drink and felt incapacitated before being assaulted.

In another case, a woman recounts meeting Tal and Oren Alexander in Miami in 2011, where they claimed they had exclusive access to an after-party. She alleges that upon arriving at their hotel room, she lost consciousness after being given an alcoholic drink, only to awake to find the brothers assaulting her.

Van Arsdale noted that these accounts share a disturbing common theme: the women’s initial engaging interactions with the brothers often devolved into terrifying assaults. “They used their wealth to allegedly do whatever they wanted,” he added. “This highlights the importance of raising awareness about such behavior and hoping others change their actions.”

Support for the Victims

Antigone Curis, head of Curis Law, which represents some victims, praised their bravery in coming forward. She stated, “We commend these survivors for confronting their abusers, and we are dedicated to pursuing justice on their behalf.”

Legal Responses from the Brothers

In a response to the mounting lawsuits, Tal Alexander’s attorneys dismissed the claims as financially motivated. They stated, “For months, we’ve seen orchestrated efforts encouraging women to profit from past encounters with the Alexander brothers.” They argue that these lawsuits are a transparent attempt to exploit the situation, especially as the statute of limitations nears expiration.

Alon Alexander’s lawyer, Howard Srebnick, echoed these sentiments, suggesting that some claims lack credibility due to a lack of evidence and prior reporting. He stated, “The plaintiff hired a lawyer seeking monetary compensation, yet offers no supporting evidence for her claims, highlighting weaknesses in her case.”

Allegations Against Morgan & Morgan

Defense attorneys assert that the law firm Morgan & Morgan, known for being a significant personal injury firm, has exerted undue influence over the prosecution. They claim the firm pressured state prosecutors into moving forward with the criminal case and manipulated evidence and witnesses.

The defense motion contends that Morgan & Morgan has played an active role in steering the criminal investigation, raising concerns about the integrity of the legal process. Their accusations suggest a troubling overlap between civil and criminal cases that could impact proceedings.

The Voices of Survivors

Prosecutors recently released unsettling footage featuring alleged victims recounting their traumatic experiences. One woman, whose identity remained concealed, expressed her fear and horror when confronted by the brothers. She detailed a particularly harrowing incident from December 31, 2016, when she met Alon Alexander for a social gathering, only to encounter violent behavior from him and others when she arrived.

The severity of the allegations cannot be overstated. Prosecutors allege a documented history of abuse, with the civil lawsuits filed seeking significant damages against the Alexander brothers.

Awaiting Trial and Judicial Findings

The Alexander brothers, now facing multiple civil lawsuits alongside criminal charges, remain in a precarious legal position. A judge recently denied bail, citing a clear flight risk and potential danger to the community. The judge emphasized the strong evidence against the men, underscoring concerns for the safety of other women.

Authorities executed a search warrant in December on Tal Alexander’s Manhattan apartment, uncovering hard drives containing explicit material that may be crucial to the investigation. This discovery could play a pivotal role in corroborating the claims brought forth by victims.

Seeking Justice in a High-Stakes Case

As the Alexander brothers await trial in New York, the stakes continue to rise in this troubling case. Alongside the growing number of civil lawsuits from women who allege abuse, they now face a series of criminal charges that could lead to serious repercussions. The narrative unfolding raises significant questions about privilege, accountability, and the pursuit of justice.

As the legal battles progress, the experiences of the victims shine a light on the urgent need for systemic change. More voices join in the call for justice, urging society to take a stand against perpetrators of sexual violence, regardless of their status or wealth.