Physical Address
304 North Cardinal St.
Dorchester Center, MA 02124
Warning: This story contains graphic content.
The heartbreaking death of an Ohio grandmother has prompted a lawsuit alleging negligence against the owners of two pit bulls that fatally attacked her while she tended to her garden. The lawsuit claims that the dogs, identified as Apollo and Echo, were allowed to roam freely despite a documented history of aggression.
Jo Ann Echelbarger, age 73, suffered an untimely death on October 17, 2022, while gardening at The Reserve at Ashton Village, a residential community in Ashville, Ohio. The gruesome event left the local community in shock and raised questions about animal control and property management policies.
According to the lawsuit filed on March 13, 2023, on behalf of Echelbarger’s family, she had lived at the complex for just a few months at the time of the attack. The suit contends that the pit bulls “ran around the Reserve’s common areas, eventually attacking Jo Ann while she was peacefully gardening.”
Witnesses reported hearing Echelbarger’s screams as the pets attacked her. The legal filing described the attack as one that inflicted severe physical and mental suffering on Echelbarger. “Part of Jo Ann’s harm was the extreme and severe conscious physical and mental pain and suffering she experienced in the moments before, during and after being viciously attacked and prior to her death,” the lawsuit states. Disturbingly, portions of the incident were captured on video.
The situation was even more tragic due to Echelbarger’s well-documented fear of dogs, stemming from a previous bite she suffered as a child. The lawsuit indicated that this fear exacerbated the terror she experienced during her final moments.
In a desperate attempt to stop the chaos, local police were forced to shoot the attacking dogs. Even after being struck, one of the dogs reportedly continued its assault before fleeing back into the Withers’ residence. “The dogs were so aggressive and persistent in their menacing, violent, and aggressive behavior that the police were forced to shoot and kill the dogs to end the terror,” the lawsuit alleges.
This attack was not the first incident involving Apollo and Echo. The lawsuit details prior violent occurrences linked to the pit bulls, including an alarming event in October 2023 when Apollo attacked a resident and killed their dog. Such aggressive behavior raised serious concerns about the safety protocols in place within the community.
Further complicating the case, the Withers’ dogs were reportedly ordered to vacate the premises based on a September 11 court ruling. However, this order had not been enforced prior to the fatal attack, raising questions about the effectiveness of local authorities in managing dangerous animals.
Adding to the disturbing narrative, just weeks before Echelbarger’s death, police had responded to a call regarding the dogs after they had allegedly ingested cocaine belonging to Adam Withers. “The body cam footage of the incident reveals that Ashville PD called the Warden’s Office to no avail,” the lawsuit claims. This failure to manage the dogs and enforce regulations has prompted the family’s legal team to push for accountability.
In an official statement, Rex H. Elliott, the lawyer representing Echelbarger’s family, criticized both the residential complex’s management and the Pickaway County Dog Warden for neglecting their responsibilities. “The fact is that if the Dog Warden or Condo Association had done their jobs, Jo Ann Echelbarger would be alive today, and her family would not have to live with this profound loss or the constant memory of the horrific nature in which she was killed,” Elliott stated. He emphasized that these failures were directly linked to the tragic outcome.
Echelbarger was not only a mother and grandmother but also a beloved member of her community. The impact of her death has left a void that many are struggling to comprehend. “These failures resulted in the death of a wonderful 73-year-old wife, mother, and grandmother,” Elliott lamented.
As the lawsuit proceeds, many within the community are left to grapple with the haunting reality of the incident and the safety of their own neighborhoods. Questions remain about how such an event could occur in a residential area and what measures will be implemented to prevent similar tragedies in the future.
Locals have expressed concerns over the management of dangerous animals, as well as the protocols in place to protect residents. Advocates are demanding stricter enforcement of animal control laws and better communication between property managers and law enforcement to enhance safety measures.
This tragic case not only highlights the dangers posed by aggressive pets but also brings attention to the responsibilities of pet owners and local authorities in ensuring community safety. The Echelbarger family seeks justice for their lost loved one while simultaneously igniting a crucial conversation about pet ownership and public safety.
Reflections on a Life Cut Short
Jo Ann Echelbarger’s story is one of loss and tragedy, evoking deep empathy from those who learn of her ordeal. As the legal battle continues, the community remains hopeful that lasting changes will stem from this heartbreaking incident, ensuring that no other family must endure such a loss. Echelbarger’s death serves as a reminder of the responsibilities that come with pet ownership and the need for vigilance in managing dangerous animals.
