Reflections on Two Historic Papacies: From John Paul II to Pope Francis

Reflections on Two Historic Papacies: From John Paul II to Pope Francis

Two popes, Pope Francis and John Paul II, saw their deaths occur nearly twenty years apart. Both figures gained worldwide recognition and shared a personal approach that resonated with many. Despite these similarities, their distinct styles left a profound impact on the Catholic Church and its followers. I had the privilege of covering both papacies, an experience that shaped my understanding of their legacies.

The announcement of Pope Francis’ passing arrived as I returned to London after an Easter weekend in the United States. Many were taken aback by the sudden news, especially since Francis had appeared to be recovering despite escalating health challenges. The call for immediate coverage transformed what should have been a restful night into an urgent journey to our UK studio.

Live coverage enabled me to discuss a remarkable leader, fondly known as the “People’s Pope.” His tenure spanned 12 years, during which he emerged as a staunch advocate for the marginalized and a voice for the world’s oppressed, including victims of war, hunger, and poverty. He championed crucial global issues such as inequality and climate change while tackling controversial topics within the Church, including the sexual abuse crisis and the roles of women and LGBTQ+ individuals. Through it all, Francis maintained a personal touch characterized by humility and a sense of humor.

Memories of John Paul II flooded back as I covered the news of Francis. I vividly recall my time in Vatican City during a cold April evening in 2005, reporting alongside the Fox News team. As the world awaited news from the Apostolic Palace, where John Paul II lay near death, thousands gathered in St. Peter’s Square for a massive vigil. Then, the lights in the palace went out, signaling the end for a man who had become synonymous with hope and compassion.

That night, we recounted the life of John Paul II, who emerged as a strong advocate for freedom and democracy. He played a pivotal role in the fall of communism in Poland and other parts of Eastern Europe. For 26 years, I had the honor of covering his journey, starting as a young producer at the conclave in 1978.

In both instances of papal death, Vatican officials expressed a similar sentiment. They referred to the papal transition using the phrase, “He has returned to the house of his father,” marking the end of an era.

The Transition Process

The death of a pope initiates a complex process within the Vatican as it prepares to hand over leadership of the Catholic Church, comprising 1.3 billion followers globally, to a new pontiff. This transition involves elaborate funeral ceremonies followed by the selection drama of a new pope. Cardinals convene in a conclave marked by the symbolism of black smoke for no decision and white smoke representing the election of a new leader. The inauguration then ushers in a new chapter for the Church.

After John Paul II’s death, the cardinals elected Pope Benedict XVI, a more conservative and elderly leader compared to his predecessor. Benedict served only eight years before resigning, paving the way for another conclave that ultimately chose Pope Francis, an Argentinian who promised a more progressive approach.

The Next Papal Election

Both John Paul II and Pope Francis initially emerged as long-shot candidates yet ultimately reshaped the papacy. In light of Francis’ death, speculation mounts regarding the upcoming papal election. Questions arise about whether the Church will revert to its Italian roots or expand its horizons to embrace a leader from a different country or continent. Will the new pope uphold Francis’ modern approach or steer the Church back to a conservative stance?

The next few days will reveal much about the direction of the Catholic Church.

Personal Reflections

Many of us retain personal reminders of those we’ve lost. For me, it comes in the form of rosary beads blessed by John Paul II, a cherished gift from a Vatican insider in 2005. These beads have traveled with me through challenging environments, including Afghanistan, Iraq, the Middle East, and Ukraine, serving as a constant reminder of faith.

I also reflect on the memory of my late mother, a devoted admirer of John Paul II. She battled Lou Gehrig’s disease, a condition that can be as debilitating as the complications that John Paul II faced in his final days due to Parkinson’s disease.

My mother, raised in humble circumstances, would have admired Pope Francis’ authentic faith and his choice to pass quietly after Easter, prioritizing the sacredness of that holy day for millions of Christians. In my family, we often humorously speculate that she lingered until after my birthday, embodying her selflessness until the end.

Honoring a Legacy

Rest in peace, Pope Francis. As you join your friends in the eternal realm, I trust that your compassionate spirit will continue to inspire and uplift countless souls across the globe.