Scammers Exploit Venmo Accounts, Targeting Charitable Donations

In an era defined by digital transactions, platforms like Venmo, Zelle, Cash App, and PayPal have revolutionized how individuals and organizations exchange money. While these applications offer a convenient method for sending funds, they also present significant risks. Sending money to the wrong recipient can mean permanent loss, with scant hope for recovery, especially when dealing with deceptive usernames and ineffective support systems.

Exploiting Crisis Moments

This vulnerability intensifies during times of crisis. Whether during natural disasters, social movements, or health emergencies, people often feel compelled to give generously. Scammers keenly exploit this human impulse. A notable case was a fake Venmo account impersonating a Minnesota nonprofit in the aftermath of George Floyd’s death. Although it appeared legitimate, the funds intended for charity vanished without a trace.

Targeted Nonprofits

Another example involves Miles Perret Cancer Services, a nonprofit based in Louisiana. Scammers created a fraudulent Venmo account that closely resembles the official handle of this cancer-support organization. This deceptive account has misled well-meaning donors into believing they are contributing to a worthy cause.

Miles Perret Cancer Services (MPCS) serves families facing cancer diagnosis and treatment. Unfortunately, they recently exposed that a fake Venmo account has imitated their official account. Their legitimate handle is @milesperretcs, while the scam account uses @milesperretcs_, a nearly indistinguishable imitation.

The Perils of Deceptive Methods

To many, this minute difference in username might go unnoticed, emphasizing the danger of such scams. Timothy Rinaldi, executive director of MPCS, expressed his frustration, stating that they had reported the fraud through the app more than 24 hours earlier without any meaningful follow-up from Venmo. Efforts to explore live chat support met with abrupt closure and no resolution.

Rather than providing assistance, Venmo’s response linked Rinaldi to generic FAQs and legal disclaimers. Even after engaging with a live support agent, the replies consisted of scripted responses claiming the issue was escalated, with only a vague promise of resolution in the next three to five business days.

Patterns of Fraud

Fake Venmo accounts have proliferated in recent years, particularly during donation drives for various causes, including hurricane relief, animal shelters, and medical assistance funds. The scheme is straightforward: modify a well-known nonprofit’s username just slightly and capitalize on the goodwill momentum. By the time these scams are uncovered, the funds are long gone, and the damage is irreversible.

The incident with MPCS is one among many. In December 2024, Final Victory Animal Rescue, a South Carolina-based nonprofit, became aware of a fraudulent Venmo account impersonating their organization, causing confusion among donors. General manager Michael Sniezek confirmed the account had begun receiving donations before it was flagged.

Additionally, the Alone No More Dog Rescue, located in Phoenix, publicly advised its past donors about fraudulent Venmo accounts soliciting additional funds under misleading pretenses.

Submitting Reports and Uncertainty

MPCS has filed a complaint with the Federal Trade Commission regarding the fraudulent activity, yet there is no guarantee for swift action. As of the latest updates, the bogus account remains operational, leaving many to wonder how much money has already been lost and whether any recovery by Venmo might occur.

Protecting Yourself from Scams

Clearly, scammers do not restrict their efforts to charities; they are targeting anyone. Here are several ways to safeguard yourself and maintain your financial security:

1) Always access payment apps directly from official sources. Refrain from using third-party platforms or external webpages to access your accounts.

2) Adjust security settings promptly. Utilize the most protective options available on your payment app.

3) Use personal data removal services for better privacy. Scammers can harvest details from data broker sites, which can aid in their fraudulent activities. These services can minimize your risk.

4) Utilize strong, unique passwords. Employ a password manager to create complex, secure passwords to bolster security.

5) Activate two-factor authentication. This adds an additional layer of security, requiring confirmation via another device to complete logins.

6) Ensure your device is secure. Always lock your devices with passcodes and log out of apps after use.

7) Confirm identities before transacting. Always verify the legitimacy of users before sending money.

8) Prefer credit cards over debit cards. Credit cards often provide better protection against fraud than debit cards.

9) Minimize balances in payment apps. This strategy makes it easier for banks to address fraud cases than relying on money-transfer apps.

10) Use antivirus software and avoid unknown links. This helps shield against malicious software that could compromise personal data.

11) Regularly review account activities. Set up notifications from your payment app for any suspicious transactions.

Responsibility and Accountability

Payment apps like Venmo function within a less regulated environment than traditional banks. While these services enable rapid donations, they must also ensure transaction safety. When nonprofits struggle to protect their identity, it raises questions about the viability of these platforms.

Should payment service providers take responsibility for losses incurred from impersonation scams? Share your thoughts by contacting us. Your input matters in shaping a safer financial landscape.

For ongoing updates and tech alerts, subscribe to our newsletter. Stay informed and protect yourself online.