Physical Address
304 North Cardinal St.
Dorchester Center, MA 02124
EXCLUSIVE REPORT — A legal organization closely aligned with former President Donald Trump, known as America First Legal, has initiated a series of Freedom of Information Act requests aimed at scrutinizing a controversial organ transplant initiative from the Biden administration. The initiative has drawn criticism, prompting concerns about potential misuse of power.
The requests were directed to several governmental entities including the Department of Health and Human Services, the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, and the Health Resources and Services Administration. The focal point of the investigation is the Increasing Organ Transplant Access Model, a program that seeks to enhance kidney transplant accessibility. Officially finalized in December 2024, this program is set to launch in July 2025, but Trump officials express apprehension regarding its susceptibility to outside manipulation.
This organ transplant model is crafted from previous payment experiments that assess whether incentives or penalties can improve medical care while broadening access for Medicare and Medicaid beneficiaries.
Critics from the Trump administration, along with America First Legal, argue that the framework is at risk of being swayed by external interests. This ongoing investigation has spurred the organization’s decision to file FOIA requests.
Significantly, findings released earlier this year from a study led by the Health Resources and Services Administration raised troubling questions. The probe revealed that third-party groups or profit-driven entities could have excessively influenced the IOTA Model, though the specific nature and degree of this influence remain ambiguous.
In light of the study, HHS Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. acknowledged serious concerns, stating that the review uncovered “clear negligence and disturbing practices” from a major organ procurement organization in the U.S. This prompted him to initiate a new reform effort.
When previewing the FOIA requests to Fox News Digital, America First Legal emphasized its worries regarding patient welfare, the potential for unethical behavior, and the fairness of organ allocation processes.
The requests include a comprehensive list of documents related to the organ transplant program and associated communications. This encompasses emails, letters, memos, and all pertinent correspondence between agency teams and outside representatives concerning the IOTA Model’s development or execution. Additionally, they seek to obtain records from meetings, including agendas and summaries that capture discussions amongst agency personnel and external officials.
The impact of the payment model will extend across more than 100 transplant hospitals in the U.S. over a six-year timeframe, introducing obligatory financial rewards and penalties based on a conclusive performance score.
IOTA was heralded as a pivotal strategy aimed at alleviating the strains of organ donor shortages and improving access to transplant surgery in the U.S. This initiative seeks to address a troubling roster of patients—approximately 90,000 individuals—as of the previous fall—who are in dire need of transplants.
Under the guidelines outlined by the final rule from CMS, participating hospitals will be evaluated across three critical performance metrics: transplant volume, matching efficiency, and the outcomes of these patients post-surgery. Nevertheless, the possible influence of external groups during the formulation of the final rule has prompted scrutiny from Trump’s allies, including America First Legal.
Laura Stell, a counsel for America First Legal, articulated significant concerns in a statement to Fox News Digital, insisting that “Self-interested third parties should play no role in shaping America’s organ transplant policy.”
She further emphasized the necessity for clarity, stating, “Where monetary incentives and penalties are concerned, it is imperative to ensure that CMS has architected the program free from influence by parties that may harbor dubious intentions.”
Though America First Legal is not officially part of the Trump administration, its foundation was spearheaded by long-time Trump adviser Stephen Miller following Trump’s initial term in office. Miller had resigned from the organization before returning to the White House in 2025 as Trump’s deputy chief of staff.
The unfolding investigation raises critical questions about oversight and ethics within federal health initiatives, indicating a broader dialogue about the integrity of government programs designed to safeguard public welfare. As the public awaits further developments, the spotlight remains firmly fixed on the intersection of policy, ethics, and healthcare in America.
