Physical Address
304 North Cardinal St.
Dorchester Center, MA 02124
Transgender Athlete Sadie Schreiner Halts Competition Amid Controversial NCAA Policy Changes
Sadie Schreiner, a transgender track and field athlete, has announced her decision to discontinue competing for the Rochester Institute of Technology’s women’s track and field team. This development arises in the wake of significant changes to the NCAA’s gender eligibility policies.
According to a spokesperson from RIT, the athletic program will adhere to the new NCAA guidelines, which reflect the recent executive order signed by former President Donald Trump. This order prohibits transgender athletes from participating in women’s sports.
We continue to follow the NCAA participation policy for transgender student-athletes following the Trump administration’s executive order. Sadie is not participating in the next meet.
The NCAA formally revised its gender eligibility policies on February 6, coinciding with Trump’s order, to effectively ban biological males from competing on women’s teams.
A newly implemented policy states that a student-athlete assigned male at birth is not permitted to compete on a women’s team. However, the NCAA does allow these athletes to practice with women’s teams and to access various benefits.
Specifically, the policy maintains that a student-athlete assigned male at birth may still practice on an NCAA women’s team and receive all benefits applicable to student-athletes.
As of now, RIT has not confirmed whether Schreiner has officially been removed from the team roster or if she is still involved in practice sessions. Her player profile remains available on the official RIT athletics website.
Schreiner’s Impact in Women’s Track and Field
Schreiner has been a contentious figure in women’s track and field throughout the year, especially following her participation in the 2024 NCAA Division III Outdoor Track & Field Championship in May. In that event, Schreiner finished last in the 400-meter race, yet the spot she occupied could have been allocated to a biological female athlete.
Earlier in May, during the Liberty League Championship, Schreiner excelled, winning both the women’s 200-meter and 400-meter events, simultaneously breaking the record for the 400-meter dash. Interestingly, experts noted she would have finished significantly lower in a men’s event based on her performance.
In January, Schreiner shared her experiences following a race against female competitors, expressing her disappointment in her performance and noting challenges during the event.
Despite these challenges, the athlete stated, the good news is that the season just started, and I’m going to leave everything on the track at nationals, expressing her commitment to improve.
A Call for Equal Opportunities
Schreiner has also publicly criticized various states and colleges for not offering her a full scholarship when she expressed interest in transferring last December. She attributes this difficulty to laws in 25 states that restrict trans athletes from participating on teams for girls and women.
Every student-athlete faces certain hurdles during transfers; however, Schreiner indicated that the challenges were amplified due to her transgender identity. She stated, among all the hurdles transfers usually have, there is an extra layer because it is trans. Fifty percent of the country banned me from participating, making it impossible to attend numerous colleges even if they extended full ride offers.
She further noted that even coaching staff eager to recruit her were often thwarted by institutional policies, leading to significant frustration.
The Future of Transgender Athletes in College Sports
As it stands, Schreiner’s path to competing on women’s college teams appears to be blocked due to the NCAA’s newly updated policies. Nonetheless, she retains the possibility of competing on men’s teams, contingent upon meeting other eligibility requirements.
The policy clearly states that regardless of sex assigned at birth or gender identity, a student-athlete may participate in NCAA men’s sports, provided they also meet all other NCAA eligibility criteria.
Final Thoughts on NCAA Policy and Transgender Athletes
The evolution of the NCAA’s gender eligibility policies has sparked extensive debate not only in the realm of sports but also within broader societal contexts. While some advocate for fair competition, others highlight the importance of inclusivity and equal opportunities for all athletes, regardless of gender identity.
As discussions surrounding these policies continue, the impact on athletes like Sadie Schreiner serves as a powerful reminder of the complexities and challenges faced by transgender individuals in sports today. Schreiner’s story exemplifies the ongoing struggle for recognition and acceptance within the competitive landscape.
As the sports community grapples with these changes, the conversations initiated by cases like Schreiner’s will likely shape the future of inclusivity in collegiate athletics.
Stay informed and engaged with the latest developments in sports as we continue to cover stories that matter.
