Physical Address
304 North Cardinal St.
Dorchester Center, MA 02124
California Girls’ Track Championship Sparks Controversy Over Transgender Inclusion
This weekend, California high school girls’ track and field athletes will take center stage at the state championship in Clovis. This event is poised to be not just a sports competition but also a focal point of the national debate surrounding transgender inclusion in girls’ sports.
The competition will feature a trans athlete participating in several events, raising concerns and prompting expected protests from spectators. Whether the athletes themselves will join these protests remains uncertain.
Voices from Past Champions
Prominent former female athletes have publicly expressed their support for the girls competing in the championship, urging them to voice their concerns over California’s policies on transgender athletes. Paula Scanlan, a former swimmer at the University of Pennsylvania, has emerged as a notable critic after sharing a locker room with trans athlete Lia Thomas during the contentious 2021-22 swimming season.
Scanlan has been vocal about her discontent with the California Interscholastic Federation (CIF) and has called on the current athletes to take a stand during the events in Clovis. She stated, “This is make or break for California. Even Democrats recognize this isn’t just a bipartisan issue. I support these female athletes, and I know most Americans stand with them too.”
Setting the Stage for Protest
Another athlete, Alanna Turner, gained international attention earlier this month when she refused to compete against a trans opponent in Maryland. Turner emphasizes the importance of female athletes standing firm against what she perceives as an unfair advantage for biological males in women’s events.
“These young women need to advocate for their rights, as CIF has compromised their competitive opportunities,” Turner stated, expressing admiration for Katie McGuinness, a La Canada High School athlete who publicly criticized the CIF following her second-place finish behind a trans competitor.
McGuinness has openly suggested that the CIF should revise its policies to ensure fairness. Turner lauded her bravery, stating, “Katie is right. This issue demands immediate attention, and CIF should abandon its transgender policies to comply with federal mandates and Title IX.”
A Call for Courage
One athlete, McNabb, has taken a strong stance after enduring severe injuries resulting from a match against a trans competitor in 2022. McNabb has become a passionate advocate for fairness in women’s sports and recently testified before Congress on the issue. She advised the Clovis competitors that they have the right to refuse to participate if they feel their chances are unfairly compromised.
“You’ve trained hard for this,” McNabb emphasized. “You should not feel compelled to choose silence over fairness. You have every right to stand up for yourselves.”
The Dilemma Facing Athletes
CeCe Soule, a former track and field athlete from Connecticut, is another significant voice on this topic. After experiencing the fallout of trans athletes competing in her events, Soule understands the challenging choices these California girls face. While she does not explicitly encourage athletes to withdraw from competition, she supports those who wish to demonstrate their concerns openly.
“Competing is important, but if they feel the situation is unfair, they should take a stand in whatever way feels right to them,” Soule remarked. She shared her own hardships resulting from similar circumstances, which caused her to miss opportunities for scholarships and attention from college scouts.
Resistance and Support
In recent weeks, some California athletes have proactively voiced their dissent against CIF policies. At the sectional finals on May 17, Crean Lutheran High School’s Reese Hogan stepped forward to claim the top spot on the medal podium for the triple jump after a trans athlete opted to step down. This act of defiance garnered significant attention and ignited discussions surrounding the policies governing girls’ sports in California.
Furthermore, during the Southern Sectional Prelims earlier this month, several athletes wore shirts proclaiming their support for girls’ sports, showcasing signs that explicitly called out the CIF’s controversial guidelines. Unfortunately, CIF officials intervened and required many of these athletes to remove their shirts, an action that the CIF confirmed occurred.
The Legal Landscape
Ryan Bangert, a Title IX expert from the Alliance Defending Freedom, pointed out that these athletes have a right to express their views peacefully during the championship weekend. He warned CIF that any retaliation against protesting athletes could infringe upon First Amendment rights, emphasizing that California must uphold these rights.
“All government entities, including CIF, must comply with the First Amendment. California faces additional scrutiny if it disregards these rights in protecting an ideology that many view as inadequate,” Bangert noted. He advised the athletes to consider their legal options if faced with obstacles to their participation.
The situation surrounding the California girls’ track and field championship encapsulates a broader national conversation regarding gender identity, sports, and equality. This weekend’s events in Clovis will not only showcase athletic talent but also illuminate the pressing issues that female athletes are grappling with today.
Empowering the Next Generation
The stakes are undeniably high as the meet progresses. Female athletes find themselves at a crucial crossroads, where their voices can lead to significant changes in policies affecting their sports. They are not just competing for titles; they are standing up for their rights, the rights of future generations, and the integrity of women’s sports.
The resilience and courage shown by these athletes could inspire a broader movement toward fairness in sports. The outcome of this championship, therefore, may extend far beyond track and field, potentially influencing policies across the nation.
