Physical Address
304 North Cardinal St.
Dorchester Center, MA 02124
California High School Volleyball Team Withdraws from Match Over Controversial Trans Athlete Inclusion
A girls volleyball team from Riverside Poly High School in California recently forfeited a match against Jurupa Valley High School due to the inclusion of a trans athlete believed to be biologically male. The announcement came just before the scheduled game.
In a statement, Riverside Poly High School confirmed the forfeit, stating, “Riverside Poly High School’s girls volleyball team will not take the court for tonight’s scheduled game against Jurupa Valley High School. This match will be recorded as a forfeit in non-league standings. We understand this is disappointing for our athletes, families, and supporters, and we appreciate the community’s understanding. We remain committed to providing a safe, positive environment for all student-athletes throughout the season.”
Although Riverside Poly did not specify the reason for the forfeit, Amanda Vickers, a member of the Riverside Unified School District board, suggested it was a direct response to the presence of Jurupa Valley’s trans athlete, AB Hernandez, on their roster. Hernandez had been listed on the previous season’s roster and appears set to continue competing.
Vickers explained, “I do believe it is because they are playing AB Hernandez, and that a decision was made that the students didn’t want to. I did get a message yesterday that there [were] parents [of players] wearing ‘Save Girls Sports’ shirts. So they were kind of prepared for a protest today.”
Safety Concerns Rise Amid Controversy
Vickers further expressed that the forfeit was crucial in ensuring the safety of female athletes. She referenced the case of Payton McNabb, a high school volleyball player who reportedly suffered permanent brain damage after being struck by a spike from a trans athlete in 2022. “What this is about is there is a difference between biological girls and biological boys. And, tonight, the girls of Riverside Polly High School, they’re not going to end up like Payton McNabb,” Vickers asserted.
Jurupa Unified School District issued a statement addressing the decision, confirming they had been informed about Riverside Poly’s cancellation of the game without further elaboration on the reasons behind it. The statement emphasized, “We were notified that Riverside Poly High School canceled today’s scheduled girls volleyball match with Jurupa Valley High School. They did not disclose the reason. We have no additional comment at this time.”
A Heated Cultural Debate
The issue of trans athletes in girls’ sports has ignited a nationwide cultural debate, with Riverside County becoming a focal point last year. Hernandez drew significant media attention during the previous season when protests erupted against the policies allowing trans athletes to compete in girls sports. The tensions were further inflamed after a lawsuit was filed by two girls at Martin Luther King High School, claiming a trans athlete took their varsity spot on the cross-country team, leading to students wearing “Save Girls Sports” shirts every week.
Hernandez’s track and field season also saw considerable protest, with female athletes and their families voicing their concerns. Many wore the “Save Girls Sports” shirts at competitions, reflecting a growing movement advocating for changes in how high school sports handle gender identity issues.
The controversy reached even further when a statement issued by President Donald Trump on social media suggested that California should prevent trans athletes from competing. During the championship finals, Hernandez achieved remarkable success, winning in the girls high jump and triple jump, amidst protests that underscored the division among community members. A protester was arrested for allegedly assaulting a conservative activist during these demonstrations.
Government Actions and Public Opinion
Amidst these debates, the U.S. Department of Justice initiated a lawsuit against the California Department of Education and the California Interscholastic Federation. This legal action challenged the policies that permit biological males to compete in girls sports, even when there are calls for prohibitions. These policies have sparked significant backlash among parents and community members.
A recent bipartisan survey conducted by the Public Policy Institute of California indicated that many residents in the state oppose allowing biological male trans athletes to compete in women’s sports. Over 70 percent of parents surveyed shared this viewpoint, signaling strong local sentiment on the matter.
The survey revealed that most Californians support regulations requiring trans athletes to compete on teams corresponding to their biological sex at birth. The poll results showed that 65 percent of adults and 64 percent of likely voters favor such regulations. Notably, 71 percent of public school parents echoed this perspective, highlighting the conflicting views surrounding gender and sports.
A Broader Discussion on Gender in Sports
The forfeit by Riverside Poly High School reflects a broader conversation about the implications of gender identity in athletics. Advocates for trans rights argue for inclusion and equality while opponents emphasize competitive fairness and safety for all athletes. As more cases like this emerge, schools across the country may need to navigate these challenging discussions.
This situation in Riverside adds to the considerable dialogue regarding how educational institutions can create inclusive environments while also addressing the concerns of students and families. Groups on both sides of the debate continue to voice their opinions, underscoring the diversity of perspectives within communities.
As high school sports become a microcosm of larger national discussions surrounding trans rights and gender identity, the outcome of these debates may influence policies in state and national arenas.
