Flick International City hall building in Dolton, Illinois with overgrown weeds and darkened windows, symbolizing neglect and legal issues.

Chicago Suburb’s Former Democratic Mayor Faces Legal Challenges After Refusing to Disclose Public Records

Former Democratic ‘Super Mayor’ Hindered by Legal Troubles

A former Democratic mayor from a Chicago suburb confronts serious legal challenges after her failure to produce public records from her time in office led to contempt of court proceedings. Tiffany Henyard, once celebrated as the city’s ‘super mayor,’ now faces scrutiny as new allegations surface.

Contempt of Court Hearing

In a recent court hearing, Henyard’s attorney, Beau Bridley, invoked the Fifth Amendment on her behalf. The invocation came after a judge ordered her to supply public records that had been requested. Bridley stated that the ongoing smear campaign against Henyard, which began during her tenure, persists even after she is no longer in office.

Missing Documents and Legal Maneuvering

Bridley acknowledged that Henyard does not possess the requested documents. Instead, an Illinois judge allowed her legal team to submit an affidavit in lieu of the missing records. He characterized the hearing as a significant overreaction, asserting that a simple affidavit would suffice to resolve the matter.

Background of the Legal Dispute

The legal troubles began when Edgar County Watchdogs Inc. filed a lawsuit against Henyard and the Village of Dolton. The organization accused them of failing to comply with requests for financial records made under the Freedom of Information Act. Edward “Coach” Weinhaus, an attorney for the Edgar County Watchdogs, expressed skepticism about Henyard’s motives, suggesting she might use her election loss as an excuse to evade accountability.

Electoral Setbacks for Henyard

Henyard’s political future appears bleak after she lost her re-election bid to Jason House, who was sworn into office last month. Additionally, she faced defeat in her attempt to retain her position as Thornton Township supervisor against Illinois state Senator Napoleon Harris. These defeats have intensified scrutiny surrounding her administration.

Federal Investigation Casts a Shadow

In April 2024, Henyard attracted national attention when Dolton Village Hall officials received subpoenas from the FBI as part of an ongoing corruption investigation. Despite the gravity of the situation, it is important to note that Henyard has not been charged with any crime related to the investigation.

Trustees’ Response to the Investigation

In light of the FBI inquiry into her administration, village trustees took the unprecedented step of hiring former Chicago Mayor Lori Lightfoot to investigate Henyard’s spending practices. This decision sparked significant tension, resulting in heated confrontations between Henyard’s supporters and opponents during the meeting.

Findings from the Investigation

Lightfoot’s inquiry reportedly uncovered troubling financial discrepancies, including a decline in the village’s financial reserves from $5.6 million to a deficit of $3.6 million. Additionally, the accumulation of credit card bills reached a staggering $779,000 in 2023, raising further questions about Henyard’s fiscal management.

Continued Legal Complications

On the very day Henyard lost her mayoral primary election, Dolton officials received a federal subpoena demanding records related to a land development allegedly connected to her boyfriend. This timing further complicates her legal woes and paints a troubling picture of her tenure.

Upcoming Court Hearing

Henyard is scheduled to return to court on June 11, where a judge will determine if her contempt of court status remains valid. If the court upholds the contempt ruling, she faces potential fines of $1,000 per day until she complies with the judge’s orders. The public will be watching closely as the case unfolds.

The Ongoing Fallout

The challenges Henyard faces do not merely reflect a personal crisis; they highlight broader concerns about accountability in local government. As the former ‘super mayor’ navigates these tumultuous legal waters, the implications of her actions resonate throughout the community and beyond.

In summary, the case of Tiffany Henyard serves as a reminder of the critical importance of transparency and accountability in public office. As legal proceedings continue, the outcome will likely have lasting repercussions not just for Henyard, but for the governance of Dolton itself.

This article reflects ongoing developments in the story and seeks to keep the public informed about the situation.