Columbia University’s Acting President Criticizes Congressional Antisemitism Hearings as Nonsense

Columbia University’s newly appointed acting president, Claire Shipman, recently criticized congressional hearings regarding campus antisemitism, referring to them as nonsense in a text message sent in 2023.

Shipman, who took on her role on Friday, serves as co-chair of the university’s board of trustees. In her message, she dismissed the congressional oversight efforts focused on antisemitism, labeling them as capital hill nonsense while referencing a New York Times article suggesting that Columbia handled tensions stemming from the Israel-Hamas conflict more adeptly than other institutions.

In her communication, Shipman expressed relief, stating that this situation minimally insulated Columbia from what she called capital hill nonsense and the associated threats. The content of her message was uncovered in a comprehensive 325-page report released in October by the Republican House Committee on Education and the Workforce.

Along with this sentiment, Shipman also mentioned her intention to restore the status of student groups identified in the report. These groups were allegedly involved in antisemitic and pro-Hamas activities that violated university policies.

Columbia’s Role in Recent Campus Protests

Recent events have highlighted Columbia’s prominent role in the anti-Israel protests that erupted across campuses in 2024. In a dramatic incident that received widespread media attention, New York Police Department officers intervened to dismantle a barricade at Hamilton Hall.

Shipman, who has been a member of the Columbia board since 2013, is stepping in to lead the university while it searches for a new president. She is temporarily replacing Katrina Armstrong, who held the position after Minouche Shafik resigned in August amid allegations of institutional antisemitism.

Leadership Changes at Columbia University

Armstrong’s tenure was not without its challenges. She faced significant backlash and ultimately resigned after a contentious dispute arose with the Trump administration related to the revocation of $400 million in federal funding.

Shipman brings a wealth of experience to her role. Before her appointment, she worked as a White House correspondent for NBC News and as a senior national correspondent for ABC’s Good Morning America. Her deep background in journalism and her proximity to national politics provide her with unique insights into the intersection of academia and governance.

Shipman is married to Jay Carney, who previously served as the White House press secretary under former President Barack Obama, further intertwining her personal and professional life with the political landscape.

The Broader Context of Campus Antisemitism

The discussions surrounding antisemitism on college campuses have gained heightened attention in recent years, driven by increased polarization regarding Middle East policies and their consequences within academic environments. Navigating these complex issues requires careful consideration and strong leadership.

While some universities struggle to address the rising tensions, Columbia has found itself under spotlight due to several incidents and allegations. The ongoing investigations and reports, including the one revealing Shipman’s comments, underline the urgent need for a constructive dialogue about tolerance and understanding within educational institutions.

Concerns over antisemitism within academia are palpable. Students and faculty alike express apprehensions about the impacts of political debates on campus atmosphere, often leading to a chilling effect on open discourse.

What Lies Ahead for Columbia University

As Columbia University seeks a sustainable path forward, the leadership of Shipman may influence how the institution approaches these pressing issues. Her comments, while controversial, highlight a need for universities to engage proactively with external pressures while safeguarding the integrity of their educational missions.

The road ahead holds many uncertainties, but Shipman’s background in media and politics may equip her to navigate the complexities of her role effectively. How she chooses to address both internal and external challenges will be pivotal in defining her presidency.

In summary, the conversations ignited by the recent congressional hearings and subsequent reactions underscore broader societal tensions. Shipman’s ability to manage these dynamics will play a critical role in shaping Columbia’s reputation and its commitment to fostering an inclusive academic environment.

This report was contributed by Fox News’ Jasmine Baehr, Alexis McAdams, Louis Casiano, Alexis McAdams, and Yael Halon.