Elon Musk Reveals Controversial Data on Noncitizen Social Security Numbers Amid Election Season

Elon Musk Reveals Controversial Data on Noncitizen Social Security Numbers Amid Election Season

Elon Musk made headlines over the weekend during a rally in Wisconsin, unveiling a chart that, according to him, indicates millions of noncitizens received Social Security numbers under President Joe Biden’s administration. This revelation has sparked discussions about immigration policies and Social Security system integrity.

The rally occurred shortly before a pivotal state judicial election, capturing significant media attention. During the event, Musk also surprised two Wisconsin voters by presenting them with checks worth $1 million for advocating an end to what he termed “activist judges.” This move followed the state Supreme Court’s decision not to entertain a challenge, which questioned the legality of the giveaway.

Musk Teams Up with DOGE Colleague to Discuss Social Security

After the check presentation, Musk invited his friend Antonio Gracias, a colleague from DOGE, to the stage. The pair focused on their research into potential fraud within the federal Social Security system. Shortly after Gracias joined him, a large graphic displaying the message, “New Non-Citizen Social Security Numbers Issued,” appeared on the screen behind them.

Scrutinizing Social Security Numbers

Gracias explained their approach, stating, “We started at the top of the system, mapping the whole system of Social Security to understand where all the fraud was.” He pointed to the chart displayed, emphasizing the alarming figures they discovered. He remarked, “When we saw these numbers, we were like, ‘What is this?’” This pointed curiosity underscores the growing concern regarding the integrity of governmental databases.

The chart in question highlighted the total number of noncitizens issued Social Security numbers from fiscal years 2021 to 2025. Under Biden, the data revealed a steady increase, culminating in more than 2 million issued in fiscal year 2024, which concluded on September 30th.

Unprecedented Growth in Noncitizen Social Security Numbers

In fiscal year 2023, the report indicated that roughly 1 million noncitizens were granted Social Security numbers, a trend that appears to have continued into fiscal year 2025. The year began in October 2024 and is projected to conclude in September of this year.

This information visibly astonished Gracias, who stated, “This literally blew us away. We went there to find fraud and we found this by accident.” His comments resonate with broader anxieties about transparency and eligibility in social welfare programs.

Concerns Surrounding Federal Programs

Following Musk’s statement, he reiterated the startling nature of the chart, dubbing it a mind-blowing visual aid. These findings surface amid ongoing investigations that Musk and DOGE are conducting into various federal programs, particularly the Social Security Administration. Last week, DOGE reported that it had identified and eliminated approximately 7 million Social Security accounts belonging to individuals listed as being over 120 years old.

Additionally, Musk mentioned that their audits uncovered discrepancies in the Social Security database, including 20 million deceased individuals incorrectly marked as alive. These discrepancies raise pressing questions about the accuracy of government data.

Previous Executive Orders Affecting Noncitizens

In an effort to mitigate these issues, President Donald Trump previously signed an executive order soon after taking office. The order aimed to halt the provision of public assistance and social services to noncitizens, asserting that such benefits should remain exclusive to U.S. citizens.

Responding to the directive, the Department of Housing and Urban Development recently launched a collaborative initiative with the Department of Homeland Security. This partnership aims to improve inter-agency communication and ensure that noncitizens do not benefit from public housing programs.

Reactions and Implications

The reactions to Musk’s revelations have varied widely. Critics argue that his framing of the data may incite further division on immigration issues, while supporters hail his commitment to transparency and accountability within government practices.

As the discussions surrounding immigration and entitlement programs continue to evolve, Musk’s remarks underscore a growing urgency for clarity and reform. The intersection of social services and immigration status remains a contentious issue in American politics, particularly as elections draw near.

With polling days approaching and tensions rising, Musk’s statements and the ensuing debate about noncitizen access to Social Security numbers add another layer of complexity to an already charged political landscape. How this controversy will influence voter sentiment remains to be seen, but it certainly has positioned Musk as a prominent figure in these discussions.

Navigating Complex Issues Ahead

Moving forward, American citizens will likely face an array of challenges and discussions surrounding immigration and social services. As both policymakers and citizens digest the implications of such revelations, the focus now turns to how these issues will reshape future dialogues and policy decisions.

Ultimately, the ramifications of Musk’s findings may extend well beyond the immediate political sphere, touching on the broader themes of justice, accountability, and the very fabric of American society.