Physical Address
304 North Cardinal St.
Dorchester Center, MA 02124
An etiquette expert has ignited a firestorm of conversation regarding the proper method for eating a banana and other common handheld foods. William Hanson, author of the recently released book Just Good Manners: A Quintessential Guide to Courtesy, Charm, Grace and Decorum, claims that the only proper way to consume a banana is with a knife and fork.
Released on May 27, 2023, Hanson’s book provides guidelines on various aspects of modern etiquette. As the executive director of The English Manner, an esteemed etiquette and protocol institute in the United Kingdom, he has built a significant reputation for himself.
Hanson’s influence extends beyond traditional writing; he has also garnered a substantial following on social media. His entertaining and educational etiquette videos have attracted over 6 million followers across platforms like Instagram and TikTok.
The Controversial Banana Eating Technique
In a recent video, Hanson demonstrated what he perceives as the only acceptable way to eat a banana. He boldly stated, “No, we don’t pick it up and peel it like a primate.” Instead, he recommended using a knife and fork for the task.
Hanson elaborated on his method, explaining that one first cuts off one end of the banana, then the other, before scoring down the peel to remove it properly. He concluded by suggesting one should eat the banana slices with the fork.
The video has since drawn over 200,000 views and ignited more than 28,000 comments from viewers.
Reactions from the Public
The reaction from social media users has been swift and varied. Comments ranged from humorous to incredulous, reflecting a broad spectrum of opinions. One user quipped, “I’m not doing extra dishes for a banana, William,” while another remarked, “That’s enough now, William! Time out!” A particularly emphatic commenter stated, “Bruh, you offended the entire world’s population.”
Clearly, Hanson’s take on banana etiquette has sparked significant discussion and debate. Observers are left to wonder whether his views represent a genuine attempt at promoting sophisticated dining or simply a quirky perspective that many find difficult to take seriously.
Cross-Cultural Perspectives on Eating Etiquette
Hanson is not alone in discussing food etiquette, as similar prompts have led experts like Diane Gottsman to weigh in. As the founder and owner of the Protocol School of Texas in San Antonio, Gottsman noted that eating customs vary significantly between countries. While she described Hanson as a “wonderful personality,” she emphasized that eating a banana with one’s hands is typically acceptable.
According to Gottsman, it is rare to be served an entire banana with the peel at formal events. She added, “The best thing to do is observe the host and follow the same technique.” This suggests that adaptability and observation of local customs are key elements of dining etiquette.
Banana Eating in Context
Hanson’s banana-eating method raises questions about the expectations surrounding food presentation and consumption. In many cultures, bananas are often consumed casually, holding a status of being a convenient and portable snack. Thus, recognizing the context of dining can be essential when interpreting guidelines set forth by etiquette experts.
The Bigger Picture on Handheld Foods
Hanson’s video is part of a broader discourse on how to navigate the intricacies of eating handheld foods, which also interest him. He has produced similar content addressing the correct ways to eat grapes, rice, and peas. This pattern raises questions about the intersection of sophistication and practicality in dining.
Do these representations of formal etiquette enhance or hinder modern dining experiences? Are there universal standards dictating how one should consume a variety of foods, particularly in our increasingly globalized world? The inquiries continue as experts and laypeople alike engage in these conversations.
A Reflection on Modern Etiquette
Perhaps Hanson’s views represent an exaggerated pick on traditional dining etiquette, echoing a longing for refinement in an era where casual dining is prevalent. Yet, one might argue that etiquette’s primary purpose is to enhance social interactions, not to create barriers through rigid guidelines.
As conversations around etiquette persist, it becomes clear that public opinion will fluctuate in response to various viewpoints. The clash between traditional norms and contemporary practices often leads to lively discussions, as evidenced by Hanson’s banana video.
Ultimately, whether one adopts the knife-and-fork method or quickly peels a banana by hand may matter less than the underlying spirit of sharing and enjoying a meal. Good manners are about respect and consideration, and these principles can manifest in multiple forms.
Dining Etiquette: A Personal Choice
The debate ignited by Hanson’s banana-eating suggestion serves to remind us of the personal nature of etiquette and dining practices. While experts can provide guidance, the decision on how to enjoy one’s food ultimately is up to the individual.
As the conversation continues, it’s clear that there’s room for various interpretations of what constitutes appropriate eating etiquette. Engaging with diverse perspectives can enrich our understanding and appreciation of cultural nuances, allowing us to navigate the world of etiquette with greater confidence.
