Physical Address
304 North Cardinal St.
Dorchester Center, MA 02124
A conservative think tank has lodged a federal civil rights complaint against Cornell University, asserting that the prestigious institution employs diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) initiatives in ways that discriminate against applicants and scholarship candidates.
The America First Policy Institute (AFPI) submitted the complaint in late June to multiple federal agencies, including the Departments of Justice, Education, Health and Human Services, and the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission. Notably, Larry Kudlow, a host on FOX Business, serves as the vice chair of AFPI’s board.
The Core Allegations
The 10-page complaint contends that various internal documents, public policies, and archived webpages reveal a pervasive culture at Cornell that prioritizes identity-based ideologies over equal opportunity and merit. This, the complaint claims, results in a hostile and coercive environment.
Among the claims outlined is that Cornell President Michael Kotlikoff, who was provost during the time alleged discriminatory practices were enacted, engaged in hiring practices that effectively excluded numerous qualified candidates based solely on their race and sex.
Specifically, the AFPI highlighted a December 2020 email from a department chair discussing the university’s goal of making a diversity hire, further emphasizing the alleged discriminatory hiring scheme.
While Kotlikoff did not respond directly to inquiries from FOX News Digital, Lindsey Knewstub, the university’s deputy director for media relations, directed requests to a statement available on Cornell’s website.
Cornell firmly disputes the claims set forth in the AFPI’s complaint, stating that it references outdated programs that have not been implemented for years. In its response, the university highlighted its efforts to enhance compliance with civil rights laws by employing external legal firms to audit its policies and practices in light of evolving laws and regulations.
Ongoing Policy Compliance Efforts
The university’s statement acknowledged that misunderstandings can arise, particularly as it navigates thousands of hiring decisions across numerous departments annually.
Cornell’s communication reiterated its commitment to addressing any identified discrimination or bias in hiring processes, asserting that such occurrences should be reported and rectified swiftly.
The statement emphasized that the institution does not condone unlawful discrimination in hiring or any facet of its operations. Cornell has committed to taking prompt and effective actions to address allegations of noncompliance with legal standards and its own equal opportunity and anti-discrimination policies.
Race-Based Scholarships Under Scrutiny
The AFPI also accused Cornell of administering scholarships that discriminate based on race or ethnicity, pointing out specific offerings aimed at Latinos, underrepresented minorities, Native Americans, and African Americans.
In defense, Cornell stated it administers financial aid and scholarship programs in accordance with applicable laws.
Jessica Hart Steinmann, the executive general counsel for AFPI, expressed the organization’s stance, asserting that Cornell’s practices infringe upon federal law and the principles of equality. She urged swift government intervention to address these alleged violations.
Political Context and Federal Response
Former President Donald Trump has focused on dismantling DEI strategies since assuming office, issuing an executive order aimed at terminating such programs across the federal government. The current leadership at the Education Department, under Secretary Linda McMahon, issued a memo in April urging state education officials to eliminate DEI programs or face potential loss of federal funding.
Harmeet Dhillon, the assistant attorney general for the DOJ’s civil rights division, assured that her office will thoroughly investigate all serious allegations regarding identity-based admissions, hiring practices, and student benefits. She emphasized that all forms of discrimination at American colleges and universities, including Cornell, must cease.
A Broader Conversation on Equity in Education
This complaint against Cornell University exemplifies a growing national debate surrounding the application of DEI initiatives within academic institutions. Critics argue that these policies may inherently compromise meritocratic ideals, while supporters assert that they are a necessary measure to rectify historical inequities.
The discourse surrounding DEI practices reflects broader societal concerns over equality and representation, as well as the role of educational institutions in shaping future leaders and thinkers. As investigations proceed, the outcomes of this complaint could have significant implications for similar initiatives at universities nationwide.
Ultimately, the resolution of this complaint may set a precedent for how colleges and universities address both compliance with civil rights laws and their commitment to fostering diverse and inclusive environments.
