Malcolm Butler Remains Mum on Super Bowl Benching, Calls It a ‘Coach’s Decision’

Malcolm Butler Remains Mum on Super Bowl Benching

Seven years have passed since former New England Patriots cornerback Malcolm Butler was controversially benched during the team’s Super Bowl LII loss to the Philadelphia Eagles. To this day, Butler has chosen to stay silent about the circumstances surrounding his absence from the field during that pivotal game.

Butler’s Legacy in New England

Butler, a crucial player in the Patriots’ defensive lineup, earned his place in Super Bowl history with a game-saving interception against the Seattle Seahawks. This monumental play solidified his status as a key figure in the franchise. However, his lack of play in the 2018 Super Bowl has raised numerous questions over the years.

A ‘Coach’s Decision’

In a recent interview on 98.5 The Sports Hub, Butler reiterated that his benching was merely a “coach’s decision.” He stated, “It’s just loyalty. Nobody embarrassing nobody. It is what it is.” These remarks echo the mystery surrounding why he remained on the sideline, despite his significant contributions in previous matches.

Limited Role During the Game

Butler participated only in special teams during the Super Bowl and did not see any defensive action. While various theories have surfaced regarding head coach Bill Belichick’s decision, Butler dismissed many of them during his latest interview. For instance, speculation arose that he had been benched due to attending parties before the big game.

Countering the Party Theory

Addressing the rumors, Butler asserted, “No, I think a ring is more important than a party. I can do that for the rest of my life.” He emphasized the importance of professionalism, stating that despite being grown men, players should know when to focus on work and when to have fun.

Insights from the ‘Dynasty’ Docuseries

The enigma surrounding Butler’s benching gained further attention through Apple TV+’s docuseries Dynasty. In the series, Patriots owner Robert Kraft revealed that what he learned suggested the reasons for Butler’s benching were personal rather than football-related. Kraft stated, “What has been told to me is that there was something personal going on between Bill and Malcolm that was not football-related.”

Belichick’s Decision-Making

Kraft expressed his long-held belief that every decision made by Belichick was aimed at benefiting the team, but in Butler’s case, he felt it was different. This revelation has only fueled the ongoing debate about the motives behind the decision.

Butler’s Career After New England

After the 2018 Super Bowl, Butler signed with the Tennessee Titans, where he played under former Patriots linebacker Mike Vrabel. Reflecting on his time with Vrabel, Butler praised his coaching style, describing him as a “players’ coach” who resonated with the team. He remarked, “He has the same philosophy as Bill Belichick, but he’s a little nice.”

Looking Forward

As the football landscape continues to evolve, the ghosts of Super Bowl LII linger on. Malcolm Butler’s steadfast approach to his controversial benching demonstrates his commitment to professionalism and respect for the game. While the true reason behind his sidelining may never be fully known, his future in the NFL and the lessons learned from that experience highlight the complexities within professional sports.

For more updates on NFL developments and player insights, stay tuned for upcoming sports coverage.