New York Teachers’ Union Offers Guidance for Migrants to Evade ICE Amid Controversy

New York Teachers’ Union Offers Guidance for Migrants to Evade ICE Amid Controversy

A recently leaked video has revealed a representative from the United Federation of Teachers discussing methods to assist migrant families in avoiding Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents. During a virtual session, the representative provided guidance specifically aimed at teachers on how to help undocumented individuals evade ICE both at home and in public settings.

In the recording, which was released by the New York Post, the teachers’ union representative emphatically stated, “If ICE comes to the home, you do not have to open the door.” This statement underlines a controversial stance taken by some educators regarding immigration enforcement.

Instructions for Evading ICE

The representative elaborated on this guidance, advising, “In fact, you should not open the door. If you open the door but leave the chain on, that could be interpreted as allowing ICE in, so you should keep the door closed and remain silent.” This approach appears to contradict federal immigration laws, which have long been a source of contention.

Red Cards for Non-English Speakers

An additional resource mentioned was the so-called “red cards.” These cards, designed for individuals who do not speak English, can be printed for free. The UFT representative suggested that these cards could be used to communicate with ICE agents when they knock on the door. The message on these red cards states, “I do not wish to speak to you. I do not agree to allow you into my house,” offering the text in English on one side and in the resident’s native language on the other.

Varied Responses from Schools

The UFT representative also noted that while some schools within New York City are distributing these red cards, others have expressed discomfort in doing so. This indicates a diverse range of policies and practices among educational institutions when it comes to immigration issues.

A spokesperson for the UFT defended the union’s stance, asserting, “Sharing information so educators, students, and their families know their rights is what education is all about.” They emphasized the role of the union in providing guidance to educators navigating increasingly complex immigration landscapes.

City Policy Amidst Backlash

This guidance comes on the heels of a recent memo issued by New York City Mayor Eric Adams. The memo instructed city agencies—including schools, hospitals, and shelters—to review protocols concerning federal immigration officers. It stated that employees could allow these federal agents onto city property if they feel “reasonably threatened.” This policy shift highlights the ongoing tensions between city officials and federal immigration enforcement.

Furthermore, the memo warned that actively harboring or shielding undocumented immigrants constitutes a federal crime, significantly complicating the landscape for educational institutions.

Mayor’s Clarification on Immigration Enforcement

In a press conference, Mayor Adams emphasized that the memo was circulated before his administration took office, describing it as routine guidance. He stated, “This guidance is nothing new. We’re going to constantly give our employees…the right direction. We’re never going to put them in harm’s way.” This assertion underscores the contention surrounding immigration enforcement policies in major urban areas.

Warnings from Federal Officials

The ongoing debate about immigration policies has attracted attention from federal authorities. Border Czar Tom Homan issued a warning to Democratic leaders in cities and states that resist federal deportation efforts. In a recent interview, he said, “We’re just trying to help public safety in your community. Sanctuary cities are going to get exactly what they don’t want—more agents in the communities, more people arrested, more collateral arrests. So that’s a game they want to play? Game on.”

Homan’s comments further illuminate the high-stakes environment surrounding immigration enforcement and the delicate balance city officials must navigate.

Political Tensions

In recent months, Homan has engaged in a back-and-forth with various Democratic leaders, including a comment indicating he would be willing to jail Denver Mayor Mike Johnston over his protests against deportation policies. Homan’s recent meeting with Mayor Adams revealed a mutual recognition of the need to address criminal behavior within immigrant communities, particularly as it pertains to those undocumented individuals with criminal records.

While the political discourse continues to simmer, the situation remains fluid. Mayor Adams’s office did not provide immediate comments following this latest video leak, indicating the complexity and sensitivity surrounding these discussions.

An Ongoing National Issue

The intersection between education, immigration policy, and enforcement remains a contentious issue across the United States. As cities grapple with their own policies regarding undocumented immigrants, the role of educators and unions in guiding families adds another layer to an already complex conversation.

With federal enforcement actions persisting, the dialogue surrounding migrants’ rights, safety, and education continues to evolve. The actions and statements from the UFT, Mayor Adams, and federal officials illustrate the challenges of addressing these multifaceted issues in a landscape characterized by rapid changes and divergent opinions.