Physical Address
304 North Cardinal St.
Dorchester Center, MA 02124
Shedeur Sanders turned to prayer and resilience as he faced an unprecedented moment during the NFL Draft, which many are calling historic. The young quarterback’s unexpected slide raised eyebrows among fans and analysts.
However, for some of his supporters, the issue runs deeper than performance metrics or team needs. Notably, the comments of ESPN host Stephen A. Smith have ignited a lively debate about race’s influence in Sanders’ draft narrative.
Smith shared a text from a colleague who likened Sanders’ struggles to the ongoing NFL exclusion faced by Colin Kaepernick since 2016, following his national anthem protests. He expressed agreement with this comparison on social media.
Smith quoted the text, stating, “This is a bad look for the NFL. This feels like Kaepernick-level collusion.” He emphasized that the situation transcends mere talent evaluation.
He further criticized the NFL, saying, “All the hard work the NFL League Office puts into erasing these perceptions seems undermined as the OWNERS appear to be colluding. What has happened to Shedeur will overshadow everything else in this draft. Trust in this process to evaluate talent will be forever tainted.”
Earlier, Smith wrote in a different message, “In a different way, this is Kaepernick all over again.” His remarks clearly struck a nerve and drew mixed responses.
Dave Portnoy, founder of Barstool Sports, challenged Smith’s assertions. He described Smith’s stance as “insane” and labeled it a problematic race commentary. While expressing his admiration for Deion Sanders, Shedeur’s father, Portnoy highlighted that the first quarterback taken in this draft was Miami’s Cam Ward, who is also Black.
Portnoy opined, “This is absurd. These race discussions are outrageous. I adore Deion. I have maintained for two years that Shedeur would be my top quarterback. NFL general managers and coaches prioritize winning; the league is merciless in its competition. Owners would sacrifice anything to secure victory. The notion of collusion is baseless.”
He added, “The first pick was a Black quarterback. If teams believed Shedeur could help them win more than the other players available, they would have selected him. That’s the reality. End of story. All other narratives are mere fantasy.”
The controversy surrounding Sanders has sparked broader discussions that delve into political undertones. Before his draft slide became evident, former Democratic Congressman Jamaal Bowman stated bluntly that Sanders was overlooked because of systemic fears surrounding strong Black men.
Bowman claimed, “The NFL doesn’t appreciate Shedeur Sanders due to his gold chains and rap-inspired speech. They disregard his leadership qualities, intelligence, and remarkable completion percentage despite lacking offensive protection and a running game. While he may come across as entitled, we didn’t label Eli Manning as entitled when he refused to play for San Diego.”
He continued, adding, “Joe Montana, Drew Brees, and Tom Brady had their struggles, and poor athleticism didn’t prevent their successes. America’s apprehension towards strong Black men, especially those who are confident and self-assured, is ongoing.”
Despite Bowman’s sentiments, updates on his original post noted that three of the past four NFL Drafts yielded Black quarterbacks as the first selections. This fact did not go unnoticed amidst the ongoing discussion.
Conservative filmmaker Matt Walsh took a jibe at Bowman’s position, sharing his disdain through a mocking post. Simultaneously, Peter Rosenberg, an ESPN radio host, contributed to the debate, suggesting that race indeed plays a significant role in how Sanders is perceived and evaluated.
He contended, “Some individuals may not grasp the racial dynamics surrounding Shedeur. Regardless of whether it is relevant in this situation, America’s historical relationship with outspoken Black athletes cannot be ignored. There exists a profound discomfort among many white Americans towards figures like Sanders. Whether this is affecting his draft prospects or not, this history remains inescapable.”
Further complicating matters, fTNT Sports commentator reacted by alleging that the New York Giants’ decision to overlook Sanders for another player stemmed from a longstanding aversion to Black quarterbacks.
He asserted, “The Giants have a documented history of disfavoring Black QBs. They wouldn’t have selected a player like Shedeur Sanders, whose personality is too dynamic for their liking.”
However, this claim faced scrutiny, as it was highlighted that the Giants currently have two Black quarterbacks on their roster, raising questions about the validity of such assertions.
Conservative influencer Robbie Starbuck brushed aside suggestions that racism motivated Sanders’ draft position. He argued, “While Shedeur Sanders could shine in the NFL, claiming he wasn’t picked due to race is absurd. The first overall pick was a Black QB, and the best QB in football is biracial. Teams are turned off by the surrounding media attention, not his race.”
Surprisingly, the Sanders family has refrained from entering the racial debate. Instead, they shared biblical verses and messages of gratitude through social media during this tumultuous time.
Following Sanders’ selection on Saturday, a celebratory video captured the ecstatic atmosphere in the Sanders household, highlighting a family united in joy amid the surrounding controversy.
Implications Beyond the Draft
As the NFL Draft conversation continues, it becomes essential to recognize how such narratives reflect broader societal issues. Discussions about race, identity, and the evaluation of talent are at the forefront, inviting deeper investigation into how they shape perceptions and decisions within professional sports.
Moving forward, athletes, analysts, and fans alike must engage thoughtfully with these themes, ensuring that the pursuit of excellence in sports transcends beyond the field and into transforming cultural dialogues.
