Warning Text Precedes Tragic Murder of Princeton Brothers

The alert sent by the surviving brother of Princeton murder suspect Matthew Hertgen casts a shadow over the tragic events that unfolded in a Princeton apartment. Just one hour before the shocking slaying, a text message warned the victim, Joseph Hertgen, about the distress his brother was experiencing.

The Allegations Against Matthew Hertgen

Matthew Hertgen, aged 31, stands accused of murdering his younger brother, Joseph, who was only 26. Reports suggest that Matthew allegedly committed the crime using a knife and a golf club during a violent encounter in their family residence. In a disturbing twist, he faces additional charges related to animal cruelty due to the death of a cat found at the scene.

Probing Mental Health Issues

According to documents obtained by Fox News Digital, the surviving brother explained that Matthew had dealt with severe mental health challenges for the past five years.

Earlier on the fateful day, Matthew’s brother noticed signs of distress in him. During their encounter, he observed that Matthew was extremely upset and haunted by terrifying visions. In an effort to support him, he picked Matthew up around 4:30 p.m. and the two brothers spent several hours together, visiting a grocery store and returning to the brother’s home.

They remained at that location until approximately 10:00 p.m., after which the surviving brother returned Matthew to his residence, where Joseph was present.

The Final Communication

In a harrowing twist, just about an hour prior to the alleged murder, the surviving brother sent a warning to Joseph. He texted that Matthew was struggling with intense visions and urged Joseph to reach out if he needed assistance. Joseph’s reply was simple yet haunting: “Will do.” The final exchange sets a tragic stage for what would happen next.

As events unfolded, approximately 45 minutes later, Matthew called 911 to report a fire and the lifeless body of his brother, Joseph, at the Michelle Mews Apartments complex.

Initial Police Response

At 11:16 p.m. on February 22, police officers responded to the urgent call. During the phone conversation, when the dispatcher inquired about the condition of his brother, Matthew’s response was notably evasive as he stated that he would not provide further details at that moment.

Upon arrival, authorities discovered Matthew in the apartment alongside Joseph’s body, which bore multiple significant injuries, including a grievous wound to the head and further extensive injuries to the chest and upper body. They also noted a disturbing scene, with a cup of blood and utensils smeared with blood present in the vicinity.

Disturbing Findings Unveiled

In addition to the human tragedy, police found a deceased cat on an ottoman, appearing partially burned, raising further questions about Matthew’s state of mind during the incident. During police interviews, Matthew reportedly claimed to have entered a state of madness shortly before the situation escalated.

Legal Proceedings and Family Absence

Matthew Hertgen appeared in court for a hearing pertaining to his detention, a standard procedure in which prosecutors typically present evidence to determine whether a defendant should remain in custody. However, no evidence was disclosed during the recent hearing, as Matthew agreed to pretrial detention. This decision alleviated the prosecution’s obligation to present evidence for the time being.

Significantly, no family members of Matthew were present at the hearing, which raises concerns about the family’s support in the wake of this tragic situation. Matthew is scheduled for a return to court on March 24, as the legal process continues.

Examining the Victims’ Legacy

Joseph and Matthew Hertgen were both athletes and had promising futures. They had previously made names for themselves on the soccer fields of Toms River High School before continuing their athletic paths at college. Matthew attended Wesleyan University in Connecticut, while Joseph earned a place on the soccer team at the University of Michigan as a recruited player.

The significance of their shared passion for sports highlights the depth of the familial bond that has now been forever altered by tragedy. Investigators continue to sift through the circumstances surrounding this shocking homicide, which is officially categorized as a homicide as the investigation unfolds.

Community Impact and Ongoing Investigations

As the community grapples with the implications of this event, local and state officials are prioritizing the investigation into Joseph’s death. Authorities have committed to uncovering the entire scope of what led to this chilling crime.

Joseph Hertgen’s untimely passing and the charges against Matthew have profoundly affected those who knew the brothers. In the days ahead, a pressing conversation on mental health, family dynamics, and the need for intervention is emerging from this heartbreaking incident.

Final Thoughts on the Tragic Outcome

The case of the Hertgen brothers serves as a stark reminder of the complexities surrounding mental health and the potential consequences of untreated issues. As friends, family, and the community seek understanding, the tragic events bring to light the urgent need for awareness and accessible mental health resources. In light of the ongoing investigation and forthcoming legal proceedings, many hope for justice for Joseph and answers regarding the events that led to such a horrific outcome.